Shelter Harbor Inn

We spent 4 nights over the New Year's holiday. Wonderfully attentive and caring staff--truly cannot say enough fabulous things about their superb dedication and customer service--ALL of them rocked! We had a cottage room (with king-sized bed) with a gas fireplace and mini-fridge; it was a well-appointed, spacious and comfy room. Ask for their complimentary bathrobes--they're perfect for lounging in. If staying in a colder time period, they can provide a small portable space heater for the bathroom--works just fine to take the chill off. In the main building in the receptionist's area, complimentary bottled water is always available, and during our stay, there was always a lovely, wood-burning fire going in the dining room's stone fireplace. For New Year's Eve, before and after the simple

This old farmhouse hotel has multiple buildings on the property and we elected to stay in one of the outbuildings which has ground floor access. The main building has rooms on the second and third floor and no elevator.||The Hotel describes itself as eclectic and it certainly is that. Our room, one of the larger and more expensive ones had a rather spartan look to it with old furniture. While spacious, it was anything but lavishly decorated, one piece of art on the wall, no telephone or clock, a quite small flatscreen TV and a bathroom with no vanity. A single plastic cup in the bathroom and a total of three hangers in the open closet area was rather revealing. If you are expecting the comfort and decor of a French or Italian farmhouse, you will be very disappointed despite the rather hig

Shelter Harbor Inn exceeded every expectation and was the perfect setting for our late-September wedding weekend. From the very beginning, Erin was incredibly attentive, organized, and thoughtful throughout the entire planning process. She kept us on track with key milestones, was flexible in accommodating onsite visits, and ensured every detail — including room blocks and guest accommodations — was seamless and well managed. Her professionalism and care made the planning experience truly stress-free. The staff at the Inn were consistently kind, professional, and welcoming, creating a truly elevated experience for us and our guests. We had family and friends travel from all over the country, as far as California, and they couldn’t stop raving about the rooms and amenities. The convenience

The Shelter Harbor Inn is full of warmth and charm, with all the modern conveniences! We found the staff very friendly, accommodating and professional. The setting is pretty, within walking distance to water views and amongst historical homes in this former musical colony. You'll instantly relax!

We had a very nice 3-day stay in late September 2025. Most of the staff were exceedingly friendly and helpful both before and during our visit. However it was difficult to not compare this visit to our stay two years ago. In 2023 the restaurant was in the “new” event center. During that trip the breakfast was wonderful. Now the restaurant is in the area previously set up as a living room that had couches and comfy chairs. The breakfast buffet is much reduced and the one young lady on the front desk was busing dirty dishes, replenishing coffee etc. The breakfast hours are 8-10 but by 8:30 the croissants were gone. It would be nice to get coffee earlier, at least 7:30. As noted elsewhere, there are no fridges in the rooms. The mini split AC, a few feet from your head, buzzes every few minute