Scribner's Catskill Lodge

Inside Scribner’s lives a 4-star wolf and a 2-star wolf. The sauna isn’t insulated properly and so doesn’t work. Our first room (a lofted queen) had no view/barely a window, uninspired bare decor and a terrible uncomfortable bed. But then! Prospect was INCREDIBLE. The food was stunning. And our second room (the Mountain View king) was comfortable and beautiful. Like a whole different hotel. Service and location are great.

Amazing, beautiful place. We went for a one night getaway and not to go skiing. Which was good because it rained the the whole time we were there. The lobby was like a modern library with hundreds of books and a fireplace in the center of the room.|The room was small but modern with a fantasic view of the mountain. We had an excellent breakfast in the restaurant. Next time, we'll do happy hour in the bar and try the sauna.||Also, I left some clothing in the room and they kindly mailed it to me asap.|A wonderful place, I recommend it highly.

Amazing stay! First and foremost, all of the staff were incredibly friendly and accommodating. We loved our little room with a balcony, the view of the mountain, the comfy bed, and all the amenities around the property. Property was very dog friendly and made sure our pup felt at home. We also had some excellent meals at Prospect. Can’t wait to come back again soon!

Fabulous hotel, affiliated with Marriott which is amazing. Thanks to my Titanium status we received a great upgrade with a Mountain View. Jake and Jack at the front desk were very helpful. The rooms are spacious and very comfortable. The common areas in the lodge are very inviting and comfortable along with fireplaces and wood stoves providing both heat and character. The bar was wonderful and David and Emily took great care of us, top notch F&B service. Cocktails and dessert was amazing, we didn't have dinner there. Breakfast at the Fellow Mountain Cafe, off property but owned by the lodge was super and the baked goods looked amazing. Overall this Scribner's is a top notch place to stay and have an amazing experience.

Meh. That describes our entire experience here. Stay here if you want to pay for a luxury experience and get Best Western… the rooms were cheaply put together with no decoration or soul. The restaurant is crazy overpriced for service that ignores you and tasteless, boring food. The sauna (the reason we picked this hotel) doesn’t work at all!!! In fact, it was actually cold to sit in! I’ve added photos of the shoddy repairs and huge gaps in the door frame that let all the hot air escape. The ice rink wasn’t running the entire time we were there. You do NOT get s’mores daily… only one per room once during your stay. It snowed when we were there and everyone had to dig their cars out of their parking lot with shovels because they plowed everyone. Don’t listen to the influencers. This place i