Amara Cay Resort

Amara Cay Resort in Islamorada was a wonderful place to stay for our wedding weekend. The property is beautiful, clean, and perfectly located, with a relaxed Keys atmosphere that made it feel like a true getaway for us and our guests. Everything from the rooms to the pool and beach areas was well maintained and comfortable. A special thank you to their event manager, Christopher, who was incredibly helpful, thoughtful, and responsive throughout the entire process. He went above and beyond to make sure everything was taken care of and that our stay — and our guests’ experience — was smooth and enjoyable. We’re so glad we chose Amara Cay and would absolutely recommend it to anyone visiting Islamorada, especially for a wedding or special event. 💛

Our stay at Amara Cay was overall very enjoyable, and we truly appreciated the relaxing atmosphere the hotel provides. The staff was warm and accommodating throughout our visit, and we want to give a special shout-out to Bruce and Jen, the run runner team, who went above and beyond. They were friendly, attentive, and really elevated our experience—please make sure they get a karaoke night! They absolutely deserve it!||The property itself is beautiful, clean, and well-maintained. The rooms were comfortable, the pool area was inviting, and the location made it easy to enjoy the best of Islamorada. Service at the bar and common areas was consistently good, and the vibe around the resort felt relaxing and welcoming.||The only downside of our stay was the breakfast. It was very limited and lack

Positive: The Caesar salad with chicken for room service Negative: Bathroom towel bar and TP holder were broken, water dripped all over top of counter, fridge dripping water into bottom shelf, terrible view of rooftop air conditioning units. Definitely not worth the money we paid so we checked out early ?

Just down for 3 days with a decent sized group. They accommodated all of us with ease and smiles. They set up a dinner for us in a wonderful, scenic venue on site. Service was top notch. Big shout out to Mr. Damien at the bar for being knowledgeable, kind and entertaining. Will go back, no questions asked. -Blue Moon

Great location! Nice rooms and excellent service! We had a great view on the 5th floor. The tiki bar had great drinks and snacks. They offer a water taxi to the other resort and one other stop and I believe a land shuttle to take you around islamorada. The had some bikes to use out front which was nice if you wanted to take them for a spin to a near by spot! Will definitely be back!