The Preston Hotel

I cannot say enough good things about the service we received at the Preston House & Hotel. I have nothing but praise and high commendations for “Danielle” the hotel manager. Even before we traveled, on the phone she took the time to warmly welcome us. The cleanliness of the lobby, rooms, the attentiveness of the staff/team was exemplary. The complimentary breakfast was fresh and simple. This hotel should be rated 5 Star. Thank you so much for awe inspiring management Danielle. And to your team Alberto and Christian.

Staff was very helpful; room was large, clean and comfortable; breakfast was good. Enjoyed the Direct TV and in room electric kettle with Harneys teas. Within walking distance of the Main Street and many restaurants. We enjoyed Jerry and the Mermaid for seafood. I would highly recommend if you need a hotel in Eastern Long Island.

What a lovely boutique hotel! Front desk staff were very accommodating with getting our rooms ready quickly for an early check in, stored our luggage while we walked around town, helped brought out our luggage, and even quickly assisted with getting a forgotten item mailed back safely! My only complaint is I wish the complimentary breakfast had more food options and better seating options to sit and eat, but this wouldn’t stop me from coming back. I do recommend checking out the lunch/dinner restaurant attached as well, very delicious!

I would not recommend staying at The Preston House for getting ready on your wedding day or for your wedding night. We chose this hotel because the rooms are beautiful and we were prepared to pay the high price, but our experience was extremely disappointing. The issues we encountered on our wedding day were serious enough that upper management ultimately refunded our stay.

We stayed at Preston House and Hotel, with the bridal party at both the Preston and Hyatt Place across the street. The Howell House at the Preston was the perfect spot for me and my girls to get ready — it was beautiful and comfortable. Suzanne in sales and Danielle at the front desk were incredibly accommodating and so easy to work with, making the whole experience seamless and enjoyable. Highly recommend!