The Menhaden

Kaylee,, Jon and Alex were true professionals in making our stay here at the hotel. We booked very last minute on a recommendation from a friend through Kaylee . She was so delightful and accommodating and met every one of my expectations as far as the room request. Upon arriving at the hotel , Jon and Alex greeted us and all through our stay they went above and beyond . They were exemplary in giving great service. As far as the rooms , they we're very bright and well appointed , pretty spacious and immaculately clean. Our dog had a nice area as well to sprawl and relax. One very unusual perk was the snack area located on each floor for the guest. Throughout the day It was a "free for all ""including hot and cold beverages , various nuts, candies , cookies and chips and mornings wit

We arrived at The Menhaden the day after Christmas for a quiet getaway. We weren’t sure what to expect since a snowstorm was in the forecast for the time we were to be there. The premium king room was lovely with a nice sized bathroom. The bed was so comfortable and the linens were of very good quality. The floor had a galley that everyone on the floor could enjoy. The galley had a refrigerator with soda, milk, orange juice, yogurt and ice cream bars. They had snacks such as chips, skittles, sweet tarts, jelly beans , m&ms and some peanuts etc. These were all for your enjoyment as part of the room fee. At night, they put out warm chocolate chip cookies and for breakfast there was chocolate, plain croissants and cereals. There was coffee and sparkling and flat water for you to enjoy. The s

The Menhaden is a beautiful hotel. Every detail was perfect. Beautifully decorated for Christmas.It felt warm, cozy and peaceful. We played games in the lounge while looking out the windows admiring the village that was all decked out for the holidays. The room was impeccably clean and bed was so comfortable.Food galley on every floor was appointed with drinks, yogurt, all kinds of snacks on the house. Kaylee our host was so wonderfully gracious. Mario the GM thank you for a lovely stay. Highly recommend for a romantic/family getaway. It was a wonderful way to get into the Christmas spirit.

The service at the menhaden was absolutely outstanding !! My husband and I spent 3 nights here for a little end of year getaway. The vibes were immaculate. The location is right near the shelter island ferry and right in the cute little town of greenport. But above all else, the service really blew us away. The entire staff went above and beyond for us. They were all extremely friendly. It even snowed on our last night, and the team cleaned the snow off our car for us before we even got downstairs the next morning ! My husband forgot a razor, it was dropped off to our room in seconds. We wanted ice for our new years champagne, it was brought up nearly instantly. Extra special shoutout to John, who quickly responded to texts for any questions we had, personally fixed a small issue with

This was our third stay at The Menhaden, and once again it absolutely exceeded our expectations. Everything was perfect — the rooms, the atmosphere, the service, all of it. The staff was incredible, so warm and genuinely helpful. And John was outstanding; he went out of his way to make sure we had everything we needed. We felt truly taken care of from start to finish. Can’t wait to come back again!