The Historic Blue Moon Hotel

Absolutely loved our stay at this boutique hotel. The staff is incredible and really go above and beyond. You can feel the vibrant history of NYC when you stay. The neighborhood is awesome- great shops and restaurants. Also really loved how secure and safe the building was- you have your own code to enter so no keys to fumble with was a plus! Highly recommend and will definitely be back!

Such a great little hotel. I stay in NYC frequently for medical travel but usually try and find a nice little hotel near interesting stuff to balance out the stress of repeated medical travel and this one was a home run. Its in a historical building, amd family owned, so dont come expecting full-service hotel amenities- but that being said, I didnt miss them. Theres a cute little bakery/Cafe at reception for snacks, everyone working there us incredibly nice and helpful and accommodating, and the room was clean and big and had a great view from every window and a private balacony. Highly reccommend.

I just wrapped up a stay at the Historic Blue Moon Hotel, and I’m still buzzing from how incredible it was. From the moment we stepped into the lobby, it felt like walking into a living piece of New York history—thoughtfully restored with so much care and personality. The original 1879 tenement details are everywhere: exposed brick, antique doorknobs, quirky artifacts from past tenants embedded in the walls like little time capsules. It’s not just a hotel; it’s an art project and a story. Our room (a junior suite) was surprisingly spacious by NYC standards—super clean, comfy king bed that felt like sleeping on clouds, modern bathroom with great water pressure, and even a little kitchenette setup. The vibe is eclectic and artsy without feeling gimmicky; it’s authentic and warm. We loved th

Felt like home. This weekend was our first time staying at the Historic Blue Moon, but it won’t be our last. Bram was kind and helpful when we arrived - he welcomed us and got us settled. In the lobby we met the warm, lovely Dovid, and the insta-famous Randy, who created this gorgeous and creative boutique hotel with his whole heart and soul. Have questions about the art and artifacts you see around you? Randy can answer them. Our room was clean, comfy, well appointed, and bigger than I expected it to be. Every hall is basically a museum — we cannot wait to return and explore more floors. Also, it felt very safe. We returned in the middle of the night a few times and there was always someone in the lobby to greet us. And when we needed something, folks in the lobby were always available to

Walked in to what appeared to be an empty room with the employee very low in a chair and hiding behind the desk. When heading to the room the hallway was very warm. My room was not. While the thermostat said 62, the part of the room further away from the heat was much colder. I went to the desk on my way out for the evening and the I shared that the room was not warming up to the person at the desk. The same employee as previously described asked for my room number and shared that it just takes time to heat up (I had already been there for almost 2 hours). I left for the evening and returned to an equally cold room. The only positive of the experience was the night employee and his super cute dog. He looked for a heater in the basement, came to our room with a master remote, and texted m