Eagle Waters Resort & Supper Club

Absolutely fabulous accommodations, clean, and quiet rooms with a great view! Theres also actual cabins for rent too if you have a group or family. The restaurant is gorgeous! Its like stepping back in time. I spent half an hour just looking at the decorations lol. Fish fry was amazing, hand cut ribeye was fabulous, and the pizza is better than Chicago, they make the sauce homemade in house. The prime is fantastic as well, a homemade rub is flavored perfectly, and oh boy its juicy. If its busy... expect a wait, but its worth it! Have a old fashioned or 2 at the bar and you won't even notice lol. The bartenders Ive met, Olivia and Bob, are super friendly. There are some gluten free options too! Gluten free pizza is my friend's favorite. Fantastic experience, Ive stayed and ate here numerous

Went for the new years dinner. Just. Plain. Awful!!!!!|Food was terrible. Ran out of various things. No filet, no Wellington. Ran out of dessert. |All the things we came for. Large party and spent $1800 as a group. Overcooked lobster. Undercooked duck. |Felt bad for the waitress. Waited over two hours for meal. |Over priced and disgusting quality. |Never offered any discount or price adjustment. Just ‘sorry your dinner was bad’ from the staff.

Have eaten here numerous times over the last 30 years. This was the worst. The pan fried walleye was terrible; could not finish. No flavor and rubbery in texture. The service was as poor as the walleye. We were abandoned by our waitress after our food was served and we had to wait for and eventually get up to seek our check. It’s a beautiful restaurant, which is not reflected in the food or how you’re attended. The good news? There are lots of better options.

My husband and I got married here a few weeks ago and the day was perfect! It couldn’t have been done without Eagle Waters and their staff! The entire weekend ran smoothly, from the rehersal dinner the night before, ceremony by the lake, and the reception that night! It was extremely organized and flowed really nicely! The food and service were great - I have heard great things about both from our guests! I would highly recommend anyone considering getting married here to do so! You won’t regret it!

Don't waste your time. We made dinner reservations days prior and when we showed up, we had to stand in line for 20 mins just for service from the hostess. Then we were told it'd be over an hour wait for our table. When asked why such a wait with reservations, we were told it was because they only have 2 cooks. Sorry not sorry, but that is not my problem. Thats why i made reservations. We overhead several conversations from other guests stating they've been waiting nearly two hours for their tables. Horrible management and an embarrassingly dysfunctional system. As parents who rarely get a night out for ourselves, this reserved time for us was more than just a dinner. This place used to be such a wonderful dining experience but we are truly disappointed and will not be going back. Truly a