Fire Island Beach House

If you like sleeping with roaches, spiders and black mold then this place is for you. If you like swimming in pools that are slimy, not cared for and crumbling, you'll love it here. If you enjoy bumping elbows with drunk degenerates who mosey on down for a dip without any repercussions as you're paying a couple K for an overpriced room, then don't wait on your next booking. The staff here is something else - they give zero care for any of your concerns. You might as well be camping. Especially since the hot water never really seems to work.

Overpriced. No coffee machine nor fridge. Charged extra $50 for pool we never used. But outside there are bikes that you have to pay to use. When asked how to get there, hotel staff didn’t even know the closest pier. We ended up having to walk more than necessary with our luggages.

We have been going to the Fire Island hotel for over two decades. Once they sold and became the FIBH, they tripled the price and services are bare minimum at best. Staff is rude and uncaring (except Alexa at the front desk). Even though we booked in March, they had us move to a smaller room after two nights there. They said they no longer had our room we reserved. What!!????|So we moved, not a big deal in the grand scheme of things but the way the staff is so obnoxious, it is a corporate vibe. We used to be able to get towels, now in a room that sleeps 5 we had to ask multiple times for more than two towels. We can’t even get ice for our cooler (as they used to have mini fridges in each room, yet another thing they took away). I don’t mind using the ice machine but that broke two years ago

Cheap hotel standards with high rates. I would not recommend. Staying here is actually a hazard to your health. No joke.

This is the most mixed up review ever. I stayed at FIBH - one of 2 wedding venues recommended in the wedding invitation The location is lovely with a minimalist room that was clean with comfortable beds When I booked, I noted one wedding bride cited how well they treated a guest with mobility issues which I have presently-torn knee and recently broken ankle. I explained to the person who booked me that I needed the least stairs for the room because I have a torn knee to be operated on in October and a recently broken ankle. The room was fine, minimalist (strangely no luggage racks, chair or table inside) but that's ok. The shower was nice and the beds wonderfully comfortable if you like soft. People with broken ankles and knees like soft! It is 3 star. The grounds have a picnic ta