Bay Watch Hotel & Marina

My wife and I stayed there during August 2025 for a night. All around, really positive. Great bang for your buck and deliciously placed near plenty of public and quit beaches in a quaint area. Debbie and Larry are courteous and generous and very professional. Would love to come here again. Just keep in mind, Montauk Point is still over an hour away and getting further by the year (nothing to do with climate change, just traffic :). Great pool, clean rooms, charming and relaxing!

Fantastic experience at this hotel! The owner was an absolute gem—when my wife left her Kindle behind, they promptly mailed it back to us at no charge, handling it with such genuine kindness and professionalism. The hotel was impeccably clean, and the grounds were stunning, and well kept. Would absolutely sray here again, highly recommend this place for a top-notch stay! Though I would try not to leave anything behind next time.

Fantastic location, just minutes walk away from Ponquoque beach. Truly a hidden gem! Place was well-kept and clean, with a wonderful outdoor pool. The owners are honest, kind, friendly and family-minded. I will keep going back.

Friendly and accommodating. We were able to get a slip at the marina for our19.5 boat. Enjoyed fishing and the pool. Kitchenette allowed us to hook and cook our catch of the day. We brought needed groceries.

Reveka is an amazing host. I spent the last weekend here for my birthday and had an amazing time. The property was gorgeous with lots of seating and a unique look. The marina is beautiful as well. Any issues with our stay were solved immediately and i was reimbursed for any inconvenience. I will definitely be coming back next year. I love the gift shop as well, if you forgot supplies for the beach or your stay, she will most likely have it in the shop. I can’t recommend this place enough. The walk to the beach is about 15-20 minutes but it’s a gorgeous walk. There is great restaurants all around.