Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel

The hotel is beautiful and relaxing. They staff is very friendly and accommodating. It is in a great location on the island just off of the downtown area but still very walkable. The breakfast was excellent! I do love when the daily specials include the lemon ricotta pancakes! Yumm!

Beautiful Boutique hotel off the main square yet close enough for an easy walk. This provides the perfect recipe for peace and quiet and fun! We were greeted by Paul, part of the owner couple, who told us our room was ready early so we could drop our bags and begin to explore the island. The room we had was elegantly curated and included a balcony off the back that we made great use of for an evening nightcap. Breakfast, well breakfast is a treat. The breakfast time is fairly broad for a boutique property but don't get cocky and miss out. Our visit was perfect weather so we ate on the balcony facing the street. I only give high recommendations occasionally and this is one of those times. If you are coming to the island for a sloppy drunk weekend, however, this might not be your place. Ther

We love staying at the Anchor Inn! The rooms are wonderful, and the staff is always so friendly and helpful. The breakfast in the morning is also a great addition to the stay and tastes amazing. Paul is always accommodating with our requests, and it truly is such a special place to stay when on Put-In-Bay. We can't wait to return!

This was our second visit to the Anchor Inn. We are now making it an annual trip. The entire experience is great. The rooms are clean and comfortable with an evening treat and black out curtains every night. The breakfast in the morning is nothing short of impressive. From the European style continental breakfast set out to the custom order from the menu and then the features! The owner is so nice. And the staff is great too! Top notch! Thanks again!

This gorgeous hotel is definitely worth a 4 star rating or higher. It was extremely clean and the rooms amazing. Let's not forget about the made to order breakfast each morning. Staff was very friendly. I can't wait for our next stay.