Come As You Are Inn LLC

As a former Long Islander I enjoy going "home" every few years to experience life on the Island. This cozy B and B, operated by the multi talented Ari and Mark, was our retreat for such a 3 night visit. Breakfasts are a treat with Ari's various home made breads, popovers and rolls. Homemade applesauce and jams are also available. During the relaxing evenings spent in their speakeasy we learned about their lives in Europe and across the USA. It was fun to come home and share our days activities with them. Mark, a talented musician and choir director, also delighted us with his piano playing and singing. We'd love to go back in warmer weather to experience their back yard haven with its pool, hot tub, lavender garden, herbal garden and even a resident rabbit. |Recommended restaurants: C

We recently spent 3 memorable nights at this inn. It is walkable to the quaint downtown with a cat cafe, post office, various shops, and LI railroad as well as a short drive to several parks, the Fire Island ferry, restaurants, and more. Hosts Mark and Ari have thought of everything to make the premises visitor friendly: their relaxing speakeasy where pianist Mark entertains guests, hot tub and pool in the well manicured back yard, ample continental breakfasts with hot entree options. We have been completed spoiled by the morning array of Ari's home made breads, popovers and more. Try the homemade jams and applesauce!

It was an amazing stay, Marc and Ari are the nicest people. Very clean, elegant and loving environment. We are happy to come back and we’re very sad that our stay was so short. The breakfast was incredible. Fresh fruits, homemade bread and a lot of other freshly self made backed goods. One of the best Inns we have ever experienced.

My wife and I thoroughly enjoyed our too brief stay at the Come As You Are Inn. Mark and Ari were wonderful hosts. The accommodations were perfect and the freshly baked breakfast and jams were an added delight. We are looking forward to a trip back in warmer weather in order to be able to take advantage of the pool and backyard amenities. Thank you!

My stay at “Come As You Are Inn” was exactly what I needed: comfortable and relaxing. The room was pleasant, and the bed was very comfy, ensuring I slept well. However, what truly made the stay special was **the host**. They were incredibly welcoming from the moment I arrived, genuinely pleasant to talk to, and went out of their way to make sure I had everything I needed. Their hospitality was outstanding and truly the most important part of the experience. Highly recommend for a warm and comfortable getaway.