The Grove Hotel

Hotel staff was very nice. Housekeeping was responsive when we requested towels. Ice machine on each floor a plus as well as the microwave and paper plates provided by hotel. Room was nice. Shades did not function well trying to get blackout shades down. Was a memorable stay this year.

We booked 3 nights with the Grove First night - couldn’t get there cuz didn’t realize we can’t drive on fire island. It was late and no more ferry. 😂 Second Day - we took ferry and finally arrived but only to find out that kids are not allowed and we have a 9 year old 😆 Hotel staff is friendly and helped calling nearby hotel and eventually found one on Ocean Beach. We left our bags with them and explored Cherry Grove before getting water taxi to the new hotel. The Grove refunded all 3 nights. 🙏🙏🙏🙏 Thanks!

Overall, the hotel did not meet my nor my boyfriend's expectations, especially given the price point and the ratings we saw previous to booking. I usually would not leave a review, but I genuinely did not think some parts of our experience were okay. For starters, the floor was not clean when we arrived. While slippers were recommended- that should be, perhaps, because hardwood floors can be cold NOT because the floors might not be cleaned properly such that sand and little particles will stick to my feet while I walked around the room for the first time. Additionally, on our last night, we discovered that we had no hot water. My boyfriend and I were exhausted and cold after a late night at the beach, and it was frustrating to have to deal with a lack of hot water. But of course, things

Although we caught the very end of the season at a very reasonable price, we were treated as if we’d spent hundreds more. The staff are as professional, welcoming, and friendly as I remember, and the rooms are comfy and clean. Our stay at the Grove Hotel was relaxing and fun.

My girlfriend and I had an absolutely wonderful time visiting Cherry Grove/Fire Island for the first time, and the Grove Hotel was a big reason why. Our room was immaculate, it appeared to have been recently renovated/updated, with plenty of room for 2 and a nice mini-balcony for viewing the wildlife at the pool and the bar. 😎 Cherry Grove is a tiny hamlet, so location can't be a real issue no matter where you stay, but the hotel is literally steps away from the clubs, restaurants, shops, market, ferry, water taxi, etc. And it has its own great club (the Ice Palace). But what really sets this hotel apart is the staff. Just so incredibly friendly and laid back and super helpful anytime we needed anything - like checking our luggage when we got there early, texting us when our room was re