The Eldred Preserve

Eldred, NY · Resort hotel

Rating
4.4/5
★★★★☆ 4.4
Reviews
20
Rank in Eldred
#1
of 2 hotels
City Percentile
100%
rating percentile
Address
The Eldred Preserve, 1040 State Rte 55, Eldred, NY 12732
Phone
(845) 557-8316
Website
theeldredpreserve.com

The Eldred Preserve is a hotel located in Eldred, NY. It is one of 2 hotels listed in Eldred. Its 4.4-star rating is above the Eldred city average of 3.0 stars. Based on combined rating and review volume, it currently ranks first among hotels in Eldred. There are 10 photos associated with this location.

Customer Reviews

★★★★★ 5.0 Ashley Miller · Dec 2025

We recently had our wedding at The Eldred Preserve, and it was truly the best day of our lives. We couldn’t have been happier with how everything turned out. From the very beginning, Curtis and Matt were incredible—warm, accommodating, and completely on top of every detail. Their care and professionalism made the entire planning process seamless. We toured several local venues, but nothing compared to The Eldred. The setting is stunning, the property is spotless, and every staff member we interacted with was wonderful. We were able to take so many beautiful photos in a variety of locations around the property — everywhere you turn is a perfect backdrop. Our hotel room was beautiful, and the food was outstanding. We were even able to customize our menu, and it turned out exactly the way we

★★★★★ 5.0 Krystal L · Feb 2026

If you are looking for a getaway that perfectly balances serenity and activity, the Eldred Preserve is it. The grounds are impeccably kept, offering peaceful nooks for quiet reflection alongside a stunning lakeside trail for a scenic hike. The service was the definition of "above and beyond." Curtis and his incredible team made our entire party feel like VIPs, ensuring that every need was met before we even had to ask. I was also thoroughly impressed by the dining experience. It is clear the management took past feedback to heart, as the food quality has reached a whole new level. This is a true destination for anyone seeking a polished, high-end retreat

★★★☆☆ 3.0 Eric · Nov 2025

We’ve always enjoyed dining at the Eldred Preserve, which is why I chose to book Thanksgiving dinner there for our family. Unfortunately, the experience fell short of expectations. The food was generally okay but lacked anything special. The French onion soup had almost no onions, and while the other appetizers were acceptable, the entrées varied widely. My salmon and a guest’s pork loins were both good and fairly portioned. However, the potato gnocchi was extremely small—closer to an appetizer than a dinner—and came with no vegetables or sides. It was also not very good, which was especially disappointing since it was the only vegetarian entrée available. The turkey dinners were plentiful and moist, though the stuffing missed the mark. Desserts were the weak point. The carrot cake appea

★★★★★ 5.0 marc c · Dec 2025

What a spectacular place on so many levels! Our “cabin” was as luxurious as one can get with high end everything including heated floors, jacuzzi tub, gas fireplace, and a wall of glass overlooking the snow covered woods. The breakfast included was amazingly delicious and diverse with the 2 lovely kitchen staff going above and beyond to offer me gluten free options such as a decadent chocolate brownie, muffins and French toast. Dinner at their Homestead restaurant was a treat also. To top it all off, the acres of grounds were beautiful to behold. My husband and I snowshoed around their lake which was peaceful and fun. They provided the snowshoes. This weekend vacation at the Eldred Preserve was possibly our best weekend getaway ever! And we have had many! Bravo and well done to everyone th

★★★★★ 5.0 Kate Deyermond · Nov 2025

We had such a pleasant stay at this beautiful resort. We love being able to stroll around the lake, it’s truly one of our favorite parts of staying here. Having an on-site restaurant is wonderful, the happy hour is great, and the breakfast is absolutely amazing. The staff is always so kind and welcoming. While there was a small mix-up with our room at check-in, the way the team handled it really stood out. They were genuinely apologetic, showed true integrity and care. We appreciate how quickly everything was resolved and how comfortable they made us for the rest of our stay.

Services

Resort hotelHotelRestaurantWedding venue

Top Hotels in Eldred

NameRatingReviews
Lakeside camping★★☆☆☆ 1.52 reviews

This listing is informational. Contact the business directly to verify credentials, services, and availability.